The who and how of college recommendations: Part Two
by Maya Abdel-Wadood
Last month, we covered who to ask for your recommendations (reminder: it may not be the teacher that gives you the best grades). Let’s tackle the second step of the process: how to effectively go about securing these strong recommendations.
Be mindful of the fact that you are not the only student applying to university, and therefore are not the only one asking for a recommendation. This can get particularly overwhelming for teachers, especially those who teach multiple classes, or many sections of the same class. Thus, by simply asking in a respectful and considerate manner, you may have already differentiated yourself from others, and increased your chances of receiving the glowing recommendation you desire. Below, I’ve outlined what I consider the most important guidelines for recommendation-requesting.
- Ask at an appropriate time. The general recommendation is to ask your chosen teachers near the end of your Junior year. This could be seen as the ‘golden hour’ for requesting a recommendation because it achieves the right balance between giving the teacher the necessary time to get to know you while also allowing for sufficient time to complete the recommendation. The beginning of Senior year can be especially hectic and demanding for both teachers and students, and getting your request out of the way early can alleviate stress for both parties.
- Be mindful of the setting and your word choice. If you are interrupting your teacher while they are in discussion with another student or faculty member, you are already starting off on the wrong foot. Likewise, if you make the request while they are in the midst of teaching or during a particularly hectic class, your request comes off as an inconvenience and your behavior suggests a lack of maturity to consider the effect of your action on others.
Wait until your teacher has time to focus on you and your request. Even then, confirm verbally that it would be a convenient time for them to discuss writing your recommendation. Alternatively, you can reach out to your teacher via email to set up a meeting time that adheres to their schedule. Furthermore, your teacher is not obliged to write your recommendation – by no means should it sound like you are demanding them to. Preface by explaining your choice – do you feel like you’ve grown a lot in their class or do you believe they have an accurate view of who you are as a person? By helping your teacher to understand your decision-making process, you consolidate the idea that they are an appropriate candidate. Ask politely, and ensure that they do not feel pressured or obliged in any way – it should feel like a privilege to write about you, not a chore.
- If they agree, thank them respectfully. If they disagree, thank them anyway. If your teacher agrees to write your recommendation, express your gratitude and appreciation. Recognize that they are choosing to help you complete a vital part of the application process. In addition to thanking them in person, follow up with a gracious email. If your teacher does not agree to write your recommendation, realize that any attempt at coercion will not make them change their mind (and will paint you in a rather negative light). Rather, thank them for their time, and start brainstorming other candidates.
- Give them context. Sure, your teacher sees you 3 or 4 times a week, and may know the ins and outs of your academic profile. However, they do not have access to many key factors about your character, including your extracurriculars and achievements. When sending your ‘Thank You’ email for agreeing to write your recommendation, it could be very beneficial to include a copy of your resume. Teachers oftentimes have forms or surveys they would like you to fill out in order to learn more about you – make sure to fill these out as thoroughly as possible, and to turn them in by the given deadline.
Although it can be a pesky realization that asking for a recommendation takes more work than you may have initially assumed, remember that the quality of every aspect of your application is directly proportional to the thought and effort you invest into it. You want to portray yourself as someone who is more than a grade or a test score, and asking the right teacher for your recommendation is the key to achieving this. A recommendation that depicts you as a well-rounded character with the propensity for personal development and the potential for growth is a highly-regarded tool that can set you apart from others in this often harrowing process.
Image: Designed by Freepik